Disqualified Contest Winner: "I'm Not Going to Bite My Tongue"

Theodore Scott of Stone Mountain was the original winner of Gold Peak Tea's contest for $100,000 and a year off from work. But the company said he violated the rules and gave it to another finalist.

Theodore Scott, the Stone Mountain man who was a finalist for Gold Peak Tea's contest for $100,000 and a year off from work, plans to pursue legal action against the Coca Cola-owned brand for giving, then taking away, the big prize from him.

Scott, an attorney, was up for the money and extended time off, and over the summer told Patch his story of being a long-time workaholic who could use time reconnecting with his family.

He was notified that he'd won at the end of August, but the announcement didn't go public right away. After Labor Day, he received a notification that he'd been disqualified.

The reason: the company said he violated the rules by using a contest forum to garner votes for his video, which was posted along with those of other finalists on the Gold Tea's Facebook page.

"I immediately replied with an email that I saw nothing in the rules that prohibited requesing votes," Scott told Patch.

He said when he looked over the forum, it sounded like a good idea and could help him. Scott said he got a fellow attorney to look over the rules to make sure he was in compliance.

"Unfortunately, Theodore Scott was disqualified when it was determined during the verification process that he had attempted to inappropriately induce members of the public to vote for his submission, a violation of Official Contest Rules (http://CokeURL.com/TTYORules)," a portion of a statement on the matter reads on Gold Peak's Facebook page.

"They thought it was an inducement to members of the public. I saw nothing I did was an inducement," Scott said. "This was my fellow forum members and forum friends, and friends help each other and friends support each other in causes. Members are not required to vote for each other."

There is support for Scott's situation on the Gold Peak's Facebook page:

Will never purchase another one of your products again. A complete farce, wrote Robert Zartarian.

Gold Peak Tea and Coca Cola, you should be ashamed of the way you treated Mr. Scott. You should have done the verification process before you announced a winner, Will Sheff commented.

Go team Theodore! - Jennifer Stevens Bramley

Scott added that he didn't see other contestants following some of the rules to the letter, such as adhering to a video time limit, using their own words in it and keeping to the contest theme in the essay portion, "yet I'm disqualified for allegedly violating ambiguous rules and they're not disqualified for violating explicit rules," he said.

He said told Gold Peak that he's been embarrased that he's had to tell his friends and family that he's been disqualified. He told Patch the plan is to pursue legal action.

"I'm not going to bite my tongue and leave it at that," he said.

Roger H. Washington October 03, 2012 at 06:04 PM
Terrible way to treat an honorable man. I hope the public does not put up with the treatment of Mr. Scott by Gold Peak Tea/Coke in this farce of a contest.
Joseph Montgomery October 03, 2012 at 07:51 PM
Great story Patch. It was well written and I hope Theodore does pursue legal action because what they did to him was simply unfair. @GoTeamTheodore !!!!
Ralph October 05, 2012 at 04:02 PM
Shame on you, Theodore! You are a lawyer and should know better!
Pat Deas October 06, 2012 at 03:22 AM
Gold Tea really messed up and should be sued by mr. Scott.Surely they could have provided some compensation for the humiliation they caused him.Also, in light of his desiring the winnings so that he could have more family time, I hope Mr. Scott will agsolutely do this anyway!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »